Three different numbers show up in fluoride conversations, and people constantly mix them up. Get them straight, and most of the confusion goes away.
Here’s what you’re actually looking at:
EPA Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL): 4.0 mg/L. This is the enforceable legal limit. Public water systems cannot exceed it. Above 4.0 mg/L, the health concern is skeletal fluorosis, joint pain and bone damage from long-term high-dose exposure. This isn’t a theoretical risk at extreme concentrations. It’s a real problem for some well owners in the Southwest and parts of Appalachia where fluoride occurs naturally in bedrock.
EPA Secondary Maximum Contaminant Level (SMCL): 2.0 mg/L. This one is not enforceable. It’s guidance to prevent dental fluorosis, the spotting and pitting of tooth enamel that can occur with prolonged elevated fluoride exposure. Dental fluorosis is a cosmetic concern, not a disease. But it’s documented and real, which is why the EPA issued the guidance.
HHS Recommended Level: 0.7 mg/L. This is the concentration the US Department of Health and Human Services recommends for community water fluoridation programs. It was revised down in 2015 from the previous range of 0.7 to 1.2 mg/L, after data showed dental fluorosis rates were higher than they had been decades earlier.
Three numbers. Three different purposes. If someone tells you the “safe limit” for fluoride, ask which one they mean.
A Brief History of Fluoridation
Community water fluoridation in the US started in 1945 in Grand Rapids, Michigan. The idea came from decades of research showing that communities with naturally higher fluoride in their water had lower rates of tooth decay. Public health officials saw it as a scalable way to reduce cavities across entire populations.
The CDC endorsed community water fluoridation and in 1999 named it one of the ten great public health achievements of the 20th century based on the documented cavity reduction data.
The HHS recommendation dropped to 0.7 mg/L in 2015. The reason was straightforward: more Americans were getting fluoride from other sources, toothpaste, dental treatments, processed food and drinks, than they were in 1945. Keeping the recommended level at the lower end of the range reduced dental fluorosis risk while maintaining the documented cavity benefit.
What Fluoride Does at Each Level
At 0.7 mg/L, CDC data shows community fluoridation reduces cavities by roughly 25% in adults. The effect is smaller than it was before fluoride toothpaste became widespread, but it’s measurable and real, particularly in lower-income populations with less access to dental care.
At concentrations above 2.0 mg/L, dental fluorosis risk increases. Children whose teeth are still developing are more susceptible. The effects range from mild white spots on enamel to more pronounced pitting in severe cases. The EPA’s secondary guidance of 2.0 mg/L exists specifically to keep utilities below the threshold where cosmetic effects become likely.
Above 4.0 mg/L, the concern shifts from cosmetic to physiological. Skeletal fluorosis involves fluoride accumulating in bones and joints over years of high exposure. Early stages cause joint pain and stiffness. Advanced skeletal fluorosis causes bone deformity. It’s rare in the US at municipal water levels but is a documented risk in areas with naturally high groundwater fluoride.
Natural Fluoride in Private Wells
If you’re on a private well, you’re outside the reach of EPA monitoring. That matters for fluoride specifically because geological deposits in certain regions release fluoride into groundwater at levels that exceed the MCL.
Arizona, New Mexico, Nevada, Idaho, and parts of Appalachia have the highest rates of naturally elevated fluoride in well water. This isn’t a fluoridation policy debate. It’s a geology fact. If you own a well in one of these states, your state health department can tell you whether your county has a history of elevated fluoride in groundwater.
The only way to know your well’s fluoride level is to test it. A mail-in water test from a certified lab will include fluoride for about $30 to $50. If your result comes back above 4.0 mg/L, treatment is worth considering. See the testing hub for certified lab options.
The 2025 Policy Landscape
Fluoridation is an active policy debate. Utah passed a law in 2025 banning the addition of fluoride to public water. Florida passed similar legislation. RFK Jr., as HHS Secretary, announced intent to recommend the CDC drop its support for community water fluoridation.
These are policy decisions, not EPA regulatory changes. The enforceable MCL of 4.0 mg/L has not changed. Whether your city fluoridates affects what comes out of your tap, but not what the legal safety limits are.
If you want to know whether your municipal water is fluoridated, call your utility or look up your latest Consumer Confidence Report (CCR). Utilities are required to publish these annually. The CCR lists fluoride levels alongside all other tested parameters.
What Actually Removes Fluoride
This is where a lot of people get the wrong information. “I have a filter” doesn’t mean you’re removing fluoride. It depends entirely on the filter type.
Reverse osmosis (RO) systems certified to NSF/ANSI 58 are the most practical consumer option. A properly functioning under-sink RO system removes roughly 85 to 92% of fluoride. The key phrase is NSF/ANSI 58 certified, that’s the standard that covers fluoride reduction specifically. Not all RO systems are certified for fluoride. Check the manufacturer’s NSF certification page. See the treatment hub for specific product options.
Activated alumina filters are designed specifically to remove fluoride and arsenic. They’re effective but require more maintenance than RO systems, the media needs replacement on a regular schedule to stay effective. Less common in consumer products, but some under-sink and whole-house systems use them.
Bone char carbon is a granular media made from animal bone that adsorbs fluoride. It’s used in some specialty filters. Less common in mainstream consumer products than activated alumina or RO.
Standard activated carbon filters do not remove fluoride. This includes Brita pitchers, PUR pitchers, most faucet filters, and most refrigerator filters. Activated carbon works for chlorine, taste, odor, and some volatile organics. It does not adsorb fluoride ions. Boiling also does nothing for fluoride, like lead, it concentrates rather than removes dissolved minerals.
If you’re specifically trying to reduce fluoride and want to know which systems are certified, NSF International maintains a searchable database of certified products at nsf.org. Look for NSF/ANSI 58 certification with a fluoride reduction claim.
The Direct Recommendation
If you’re on city water and fluoride is your concern, an NSF/ANSI 58 certified under-sink reverse osmosis system is the most reliable consumer option. It will reduce fluoride by 85 to 92% at the tap where you drink and cook. That’s the only filter category with consistent independent test data behind it for fluoride.
If you’re on a private well in Arizona, New Mexico, Nevada, Idaho, or Appalachia, test your water for fluoride before assuming your level is fine. Contact your state health department to find out whether your county has known elevated groundwater fluoride. If your result is above 2.0 mg/L, consider treatment options. If it’s above 4.0 mg/L, treat it.
For removal options, see How to Remove Fluoride from Water.
For testing, see Best Mail-In Water Tests and the testing hub.
For well owners with specific concerns, the well water guide covers what to test for and how to prioritize.
Sources: